Rock paper fungus: How X-ray imaging of rocks will save papers of the past
Believe it or not: X-ray works a lot better on rocks than on paper. This has been a problem for restorers trying to save historical books and letters from the ravages of time and fungi. They frankly did not know what they were up against once the tell-tale signs of vandals such as Dothidales or Pleosporales started to spot the surface of their priceless documents
Method from geo-investigations adjusted for paper
Now Diwaker Jha, an imaging specialist from Department of Chemistry, University of Copenhagen, has managed to adapt analysis methods developed to investigate interiors of rocks to work on paper too, thus using 3D tomography data to get a first look at how fungus goes about infesting paper. Together with researchers from France and the US he has published the findings in the Journal of Analytical Atomic Spectrometry in the paper "Morphology and characterization of Dematiaceous fungi on a cellulose paper substrate using synchrotron X-ray microtomography, scanning electron microscopy and confocal laser scanning microscopy in the context of cultural heritage"
Difficult to see through paper
The results are good news for paper conservators and others who wish to study soft materials with X-ray tomography.
"Rocks are easy because they are hard. The X-ray images show a very good contrast between the solid and the pores or channels, which are filled with low density materials such as air or fluids!
Department of Chemistry
“Rocks are easy because they are hard. The X-ray images show a very good contrast between the solid and the pores or channels, which are filled with low density materials such as air or fluids. In this case, however, paper and fungi, both are soft and carbon based, which makes them difficult to distinguish”, says Diwaker.
Woke audience with data analysis
Diwaker Jha is a PhD student in the NanoGeoScience group, which is a part of the Nano-Science Center at Department of Chemistry. He investigates methods to improve imaging techniques used by chemists and physicists to investigate how fluids move in natural porous materials. At a recent conference, he was presenting an analysis method he developed for X-ray tomography data. He was awarded the Presidential Scholar Award by the Microscopy Society of America for it, but he also sparked interest with a conservation officer in the audience.
Bad news for conservators
Hanna Szczepanowska works as a research conservator with the Smithsonian Institution in the USA and she initiated the work. For decades she had been investigating how fungi interact with the paper. Does it sit on the surface, or does it burrow deeper? If they were surface dwellers, it should be easy to just brush them off, but no such luck, says Diwaker.
“As it turns out, microscopic fungi that infest paper grow very much the same way as mushrooms on a forest floor. However, unlike mushrooms, where the fruiting body emerges out of the soil to the surface, here the fruiting bodies can be embedded within the paper fibres, making it difficult to isolate them. This is not great news for conservationists because the prevalent surface cleaning approaches may not be adequate”, explains Diwaker Jha.
Advanced X-ray technique on powerfull equipment
In working out a way to see into the paper, Jha investigated 3D data collected by Dr. Szczepanowska and her CNRS colleagues. The samples for this study was a handmade sheet from the 1600's and a 1920's engraving on machine-made paper. Compared with mushrooms, these fungi are thousands of times smaller, which required an advanced X-ray imaging technique available at the European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF), Grenoble, France. The technique is very similar to medical tomography (CT scanning) done at hospitals but in Grenoble the X-ray is produced by electrons accelerated to about the speed of light in an 844 meter long circular tube. A handy comparison: “If We were to use medical X-ray tomography to look at an Olympic village, We would be able to make out only the stadium. With the synchrotron based X-ray tomography, We would be able to distinguish individual blades of grass on the field.”
Hoping to help save all manner of artefact
Diwaker hopes that conservators will be able to use the new insight to develop conservation strategies not just for paper artefacts but also for combating biodegradation on a host of other types of cultural heritage materials. And the developed methods can be extended to other studies related to soft matter.
Tel: +45 3050 6582